Fantastic guidance on reviewing all cars.
In depth descriptions on accessories and vehicle performance on the road.
How we checked this
- Submitted May 12, 2026
- No proof of purchase was attached, so this review is unbadged.


1521 Old Country Road · Riverhead, NY 11901
from 161 reviews
Showing the latest 50 of 161 reviews.
In depth descriptions on accessories and vehicle performance on the road.
about. He walked me through the process easily, when I decided to purchase. He answered all my questions of which I had many.
— fitzumb
salesman, considerate, welcoming, attentive, listen to you. Want to know what model u r looking for
Welcoming staff upon arrival. Prompt, professional service by the staff members. Notified in a reasonable time when the vehicle’s work was completed.
patient and friendly. Transaction processing was seamless. Delivery was smooth and easy with vehicle in great condition. We are very pleased with the dealership!
— Ezjohn44
HELPFUL, GOING OUT OF HIS WAY TO CORRECT A MISSED ACTION REQUEST
patient. They took their time to explain every details.
— Legend
EV from Subaru. Jimmy Delatola was friendly, knowledgeable, and went the extra mile for uS! He even answered our questions after we drove the car off the lot. Highly recommend him and the dealership to all our friends!|
— GV26
The dealership was comfortable and the sales people attentive. I would buy another car here if it were necessary.
— foxtek
I was greeted by an amazing young man Noah Greer as my advisor. Noah was exceptional at his role and caring. Generally I don’t leave reviews, however his service was phenomenal, enough for me to leave this review.. He went ii to depth and educated me on needs of tire rotation and filter replacement.
— Linda S
Subaru, everyone is very nice
— barbr1
The salesperson and GM were wonderful and reviewed the car thoroughly.
cat needed in a timely fashion
— robjoan1
service department told me while getting an inspection that my passenger side mirror was slightly cracked and removed the mirror damaging it more and then told me it was an aftermarket mirror and they could not replace it and still charged me for the inspection and I had to take it somewhere else to get inspected.
The salesperson Tayler provided excellent and concise information and was very courteous. We amicably came to an agreement on pricing with no unnecessary delays. It was straightforward - completing the purchase was a pleasure. The salesperson Tayler clearly explained the process and addressed the necessary steps to expedite the purchase and was friendly and professional.
— Ascenter
I test frozen three cars and everything was explained clearly.
Then I started to go to Riverhead for my routine service and other service that I needed on my car. The service department was always wonderful. As my car got older my friends said you know you don't have to take your car there as it isn't covered. Told them the only place I will go for service is Riverhead. Fast forward time to update to a 2025 Forester won't go any other place. As a senior citizen I have never leased a car but wanted to and Tayler was so helpful and explained everything to me. Also answered any questions I had about the car and the financing. All I can say from the many years I have been going to Riverhead Subaru from the folks that greet you to the service and sales dept. I would never go anywhere else and highly recommend them to anyone what wants peace of mind.
the Forester, especially the computer electronics, which were initially a mystery to me. He is very knowledgeable and has a great attitude.
— kss412
salesman approach. Giving me straight facts and no fluff in the sale is what motivated me to work with this dealership. Thanks again Erik
I love the waiting room, it is very comfortable, they is great hot chocolate. The car is well taken off.. I had to put new brakes.. price is never good news but I am glad they did it!!
He was very informative, helpful and professional.
He was very professional, knowledgeable, and attentive to our needs. He took his time and thoroughly explained all the various features and options of the Crosstrek and followed up to see if we had further questions. He expertly guided us through every aspect of the purchasing process and the necessary paperwork. We were very happy with our experience at Riverhead Bay Subaru and recommended the dealership and especially our sales consultant, Eric Mamay, very highly.
— Ronnie
Our salesman, Jim Delatola is wonderful! Finally a sales person who treats you like a family member. He listened to what we wanted and worked out a great deal on our trade in and the price for our new Forester. We had a deal within an hour! He is personable and was very helpful explaining how to use all the bells and whistles in our new car. I hope the dealership appreciates Jim as he is an asset to the company.
My daughter had leased a Subaru a few years and was very satisfied.
not solve the intermittent problem. Hopefully the deductible fee will go toward further resolution.
— Joycebny
Tim McCutchan is a great professional. I've purchased 4 vehicles from him over the last several years. Enough said?
and the salesman was very knowledgeable and answered all our questions and explained the nuances of the car and the paperwork needed for the lease.
techs. Professional and courteous always. Always satisfied.
forward and in our experience in purchasing three cars from him he has always done more than expected to insure we are satisfied and get the best experience from our Outbacks. I love Outbacks, but the reason I prurchase than is because of Jummy
— pithar
! The service department receptionists are were kind and informative about what had to be done to my car, how long it would take, and the cost. Thanks so much everyone at Subaru Riverhead!!!
program. It was a pain and hassle free experience. Our salesman was ready for us when we walked in. A car was moved up front earlier & cleared of snow for us to go over and test drive. Our salesman was knowledgeable and professional. we ended up leaseing our vehicle from them & will go back in the future
waited in a reasonable mount of time .
took a ride to Riverhead Bay Subaru. In past experiences with purchasing a new car were very painful (hours long) in terms of pressure,etc. However, that is NOT the case with our experience at this dealership. It was more of relaxed environment. We met with Kelly mid December 2023, He showed us a couple of new vehicles and we made the choice to go with the 2024 Outback Premium after test drive. He took care of everything, financing, insurance,etc. Professinal is an understatement. In fact, when we took delivery, he came out and showed us how to setup and utilize several features in this new vehicle. Thank you so much, Kelly and Team at Riverhead Bay Subaru Mike & Barbara
— Mike
have had a good experience. Our salesman Tayler was great and our experience with service department has been good also. Highly recommend them.
— advetch
They try to get your service done as quickly and efficiently as possible.
— chic3275
paid for Very very DISAPPOINTED
— fyngaz
professional and courteous staff. So far from buying to servicing my Outback, it’s been a positive experience.
everything was handled very professionally and within a short period of time. When I was leaving Service Rep stated my receipt of work done was stamped for a free car wash a few blocks away.
They anticipate your needs so things don’t break down while your driving.
— praso
always have a good experience. Our salesman Tayler was great and my recent experience in the service department was good also. Highly recommend them.
have had only minor complaints like things missing from vehicle. I think that for 2 ($110.00 x 2 =$220) in parts/rear shocks and a $600.00 labor fee is over the top. No dealership that I know of on LI would charge that rate. I waited an extra hour for the parts to arrive from a local auto retailer. Had the previous service person when I had the inspection done specified that I had to pay upfront for the parts so that they would be ready on the day of install I could have saved time & money! Would you give a better rating ???
— Val
leadership who listen and address issues in timely manner
— lcorker
to details by this dealership. This is the second Subaru. I have purchased from them and would recommend them. My salesman Taylor Fichtner was great.
— Brew5
Negotiating is successful at least in my case. I would recommend buying a car here.
— rdzidziu
We have my husband car & is also done great
— GRAM2MRY
Answered all our questions and tried to fulfill all our requests. Riverhead Bay Subaru was very quiet and laid back. No hard sell or funny business. Even after the purchase, no waiting around for the car. Came back on Monday to pick it up. If you're in the market for Subaru, visit this dealership.
— mikkap
helpful to me. I am 73 years old and have a few issues with figuring usage of all the car settings. They were very helpful to me. Service department was excellent. Rotated my tires , with my oil change , changed windshield wipers, and got me out in a timely matter
— Nlm56
smooth to lease a Car. Thank you!
— ltmamay
opportunity to bring my car to hands down, and you won't be disappointed with the customer Service from all the workers.there.
— Shot1478
My salesman Kelly made the entire process of buying my car a very pleasant experience.
— lynn1697